Engadget Disables Comments
Too many Apple stories - apparently, that was the reason for the backlash from comments made against the Engadget team. To quell the dispute, Topolsky himself then posted up a humorous Apple-Free Engadget, stripping the site of anything related to the Cupertino company. Meant to be a joke, Engadget soon saw more outrage, which then culminated into the decision to disable comments altogether on the site indefinitely.
Now this is what I don't get; Why punish the entire community over a couple of yahoos? I mean if you have a rowdy bunch of kids talking through a movie, yes, you kick'em out, but you don't stop the movie and tell everyone to leave do you? Comments are an open forum, so why not just do some old fashioned banning, Kotaku-style? But then again if you ban users for "talking back" and questioning things you run the risk of sounding arrogant and totalitarian - not allowing any criticism come near you, which removes any credibility you once had in my opinion.
To me comments are an immediate line between the author, the content, and a culmination of all the readers - A forum is born and gives rise to discussion and opinion - Without that you become old fashioned, almost newpaper like; a one way street where content goes out but nothing comes in, which can be damning because you no longer are writing for the reader but are now focusing on yourself.
Read the rest after the break!